Articles and Resources

If you are interested in game analytics one of the best things to do early on is to read up on what other people do. While this does not result in a plan for how to implement analytics in your game, it provides useful information guiding the design of the plan (note: cross-posted from the Game Analytics blog). Additional reading resources are availabel under “Reports and Publications” on this site, and there are links to other sites that cover game analytics under “Analytics Sites”. Enjoy!

See the Game Analytics blog for additional material on how to get started with game analytics. 

Game analytics has in some ways been a part of games since developers started looking at how people actually play games, i.e. from the very beginning, but it is in recent years that analytics has become more deeply integrated in game development across the indie and AAA. Unfortunately, the level of available information has not followed this rather explosive development, meaning that for a non-expert interested in analytics, finding useful information can be difficult. The goal here is to provide a guide to the literature that is available, with an emphasis on the non-expert.

(If you know of good analytics resources that you think should be on the list, drop me a line on anders[at]gameanalytics.com).

Books on Game Analytics

There are currently five books on game analytics, or very closely related to it/mentioning it, on the market. One is a comprehensive mastodont which covers a variety of topics, the others are focused on a variety of topics either directly game analytics or related to it. These can be supplemented by a few excellent texts on business intelligence and analytics in general, as well as books on data mining.

Game Analytics: Maximizing the Value of Player Data 

Edited by El-Nasr, Drachen and Canossa, this 800-page mammoth covers a variety of topics in analytics, with a focus on behavioral telemetry and its role in game development and research. Aimed at both beginners and experts, and authored by more than 50 experts from industry and research, it covers many important bases such as game data mining, visualization, monetization and user research, as well as topics such as metrics for learning games and quantitative user testing. The sheer scope of the book means that everyone will find something of interest inside, but it should be noted that the book is aimed at providing information and coverage rather than a how-to volume. (disclaimer: I am an editor on this book and therefore horribly biased).

Social Game Design: Monetization Methods and Mechanics

Authored by the highly experienced developers Tim Fields and Brandon Cotton this book focuses on the design and business side of social game development, and outlines what makes games compelling and why people will pay to play them. The book handily outlines different business models, player acquisition strategies, analytics strategies and retention considerations. Recommended for both beginners and experts in analytics who work with social/online games. An excerpt is available from Gamasutra.com.

Freemium Economics: Leveraging Analytics and User Segmentation to Drive Revenue

Your freemium product generates vast volumes of data, but using that data to maximize conversion, boost retention, and deliver revenue can be challenging if you don’t fully understand the impact that small changes can have on revenue. In this book, author Eric Seufert provides clear guidelines for using data and analytics through all stages of development to optimize your implementation of the freemium model. Freemium Economics de-mystifies the freemium model through an exploration of its core, data-oriented tenets, so that you can apply it methodically rather than hoping that conversion and revenue will naturally follow product launch. Written by Eric Seufert.

Free-to-Play: Making Money From Games You Give Away

This book covers a wide range of topics from psychology of players, game design techniques, how to measure analytics and most importantly, monetization tricks. In fact, considering the success of games such as Farmville, Candy Crush, Clash of Clans and Temple Run, we’re surprised there are so few books about this topic. By Will Luton.

The Curve: How Smart Companies Find High-Value Customers

In The Curve, Nicholas Lovell weaves together stories from disparate industries to show how smart companies are solving this puzzle. From video games to pop music to model trains, the Internet helps businesses forge direct relationships with a vast global audience by building communities and offering bespoke products and experiences. By Nicholas Lovell.

 

Online writings, articles and blogs

Game Analytics: The Basics

This is an early version of a document that later became an introduction chapter in the book “Game Analytics – Maximizing the Value of Player Data”. It is intended as a basic introduction to what Game Analytics is for the non-expert and forms a good place to start.

The GA Development Blog

It is shameless self-promotion, I know, but on this blog Game Analytics (the company, not the R&D field) actually try to discuss topics of broad interest to everyone interest in game analytics and game user research. At the blog, we have also started up a series of guest posts from industry veterans who will write about their favorite topics on game design and analytics. If you would like to contribute, or have requests for a topic, drop us a line.

Halo 3: How microsoft labs invented a new science of play

The article by Thompson in Wired Magazine about Microsoft Studios Research’s and Bungie’s work on game user research is one of the fundamental pieces of writing in game analytics. Thompson focuses on the specific situation of user testing in AAA-level contexts, and outlines how Microsoft and Bungie started integrating analytics in their studies of player behavior with great success.

Game Analytics – Big Data and Business

Kevin Flood has an excellent set of posts on his blog that covers some of the basics of game analytics, discussing data capture, player experience, the game state machine, funnel analysis etc.

Intro to User Analytics

Magy Seif El-Nasr, Alessandro Canossa and Anders Drachen (disclaimer: that’s me – horribly biased), writes about feature selecting, i.e. finding out which user behaviors to track in games.

Game Telemetry with Playtest DNA on Assassin´s Creed

Ubisoft has started up their own development/analytics blog, The Engine Room, where the teams there write about the highly interesting work they are doing on game analysis. The three-parter on analyzing player behavior in Assassin´s Creed are highly interesting stuff, covering trajectory analysis, heatmaps and the relationship between user testing and design. Update: The Engine Room has shut down, but Jonathan Dankoff has published the material on Gamasutra (link updated).

Applying Metrics-driven Development to MMO Costs and Risks

In this white paper for Versant Corporation, industry veteran Larry Mellon provides advice on how to set-up an run analytics for MMOGs. It is one of the few texts freely available that discusses analytics for QA, customer support and other areas outside of behavioral analytics and monetization. Larry Mellon’s personal website contains more goodies from his many years of work:

Hot Failure: Tuning Gameplay With Simple Player Metrics

Chris Pruett wrote this insightful story in Game Developer Magazine about his own beginning experiences with analytics during the process of developing an indie mobile game, Replica Island, outlining how he used basic analytics tools to get actionable insights for tweaking the games’ design. Additional analysis are shown on his website for Replica Island.

Game Analytics 101

In this great post by Ben Chong, a tutorial is delivered which covers the very basics of doing analytics for iPhone games, with some great insights for aspiring game analytics. Ben Chong highlights that analytics is useful because it provides the knowledge to change game design to increase engagement with the users.

Big data analytics for video, mobile, and social game monetizationUnderstand and influence profitable consumer behavior

Kimberly Chulis from Core Analytics talks about the move from retail-based to F2P business models in the game industry, and discusses the role of big data and analytics to drive monetization in the new market for games. Quick introduction to some of the core business metrics in F2P, technology advances in data storage and a analytics examples from games.

Do You Speak Metrics?

Justin Johnson provides a quick vocabulary of the key metrics in online/F2P, defining terms like event, DAU, MAU, K-factor and similar. He describes the more common terms and acronyms used in monetization analytics, and also provides a quick overview of funnel analysis, split testing (A/B testing) and cohort analysis.

Balance and Flow Maps

Sean Houghton shows a great case example of how heat maps is just the beginning in the application of behavioral telemetry data in the spatial domain of games – simple spatial visualizations remain a state-of-the-art but as Hougton shows on the altdevblogaday (worth reading in its own right), there is an untapped potential in using the actual dimensions of gameplay as the basis for analysis.

Tracking Player Feedback to Improve Game Design

Phillip DeRosa from Bioware wrote this piece for Gamasutra during the development of Mass Effect, focusing on time spent reports, i.e. logs of player behavior or activity, categorized into specific bins ”combat mode” or ”journal”. It is a good example of how a basic metric can be used to great effect to inform design.

Freemium Games are Not Normal

Nick Lim, founder of analytics company Sonamine, writes about the fundamental properties of player behavior, describing a surprising discrepance between many forms of human behavior and player behavior, which has earlier been described in academic research but is filtering through in the industry: that player behavior is not normally distributed but follows a power law distribution. This has a ton of important connotations for F2P games (and all other games for that matter), notably that there is no limit on player spending, and that “elder” players should not be slighted. It also highlights once again the importance the few power-spenders that drive the economy of F2P games.

Beyond the Heatmap

Yet another piece of shameless self-promotion, but hopefully useful, in this article for Game Developer Magazine, Anders Drachen writes about spatial game analytics, outlining how heatmaps merely form the beginning for how to analyze and visualize the spatial and spatio-temporal behavior of players, and the insights that can be obtained from such analysis.

Better Game Design Through Data Mining

Written back in 2003, David Kennerly was one of the first people to write publicly about game data mining – the process of discovering patterns in e.g. telemetry data. He focuses on MMOs but the insights are broadly applicable. Kennerly focuses on four applications of data mining in MMOs: Balancing economies, catching cheaters, cutting production costs and increasing subscription renewals. This feature article on Gamasutra is a must-read for those interested in online game analytics.

Finding Out What They Think

Ben Lewis-Evans has with the backing of the IGDA Special Interest Group on Game User Research written an excellent introduction to game user research and the methods used – which includes analysis of telemetry data. The primer is available from Gamasutra and is a long read, but definitely worth it, and nicely explains how analytics go hand in hand with user testing.

Staying Power: Rethinking Feedback to Keep Players in the Game

Bruce Phillips is a veteran in the industry and someone it pays to listen to. In this Gamasutra feature he writes about why people stop playing games and backs it up using analytics. He discusses different strategies for encouraging players to keep playing.

Ben Medler’s Blog 

Ben Medler is a former academic who has done a lot of work with the industry, e.g. EA, focusing on how to visualize behavioral data from games, and was recently lured from the cozy halls of Georgia Tech to the industry. His blog has a number of good posts on visualization of telemetry data, and a link to his PhD-thesis, “play with data”, which is a good introduction to data analytics and –visualization in game development. He has also contributed an excellent chapter about data visualization to the book on Game Analytics mentioned at the top.

Playnomics Quarterly US PLayer Engagement Study (2012)

Playnomics, a third-party provider of tools specialized for segmentation and prediction analysis of players, released this report about US gamer’s behavior in online/social games. It includes a few interesting insights, e.g. that players less likely to churn play more the first day they play a new game, and shows off some of the factors Playnomics use to score and rate players in terms of e.g. how likely they are to churn.

The Metrics are the Message: how analytics is shaping social games

Keith Stuart writes about Facebook and online games and the need to analyze player behavior to ensure success in the UK Newspaper The Guardian’s online blog. he describes the need for information about players as the origin of a new generation of companies dedicated to social gaming analytics.

Beyond free-to-play: The future of game monetisation

Will Freeman, writing for Develop, examines the games beyond Free-to-Play, including the role of analytics. F2P is not the frontline any more, but rather the norm inthe online and business space, and revenue generation via in-game transactions an established business model. However, handling aggressiveness and friction remains a challenge, and the article highlights that we are only seeing the beginning.

Brewing your own game analytics service

Colt McAnlis, writing for the excellent Altdevblogaday, tackles the challenge of implementing a system for collecting and storing gameplay data. He includes links to source code for sample implementations.

5 Common Pitfalls or Mobile Game Analytics

Trevor McCalmont writes on develop-online.net about common mistakes made in mobile game analytics.

Virtual Goods – An Excerpt from Social Game Design: Monetization Methods and Mechanics

An exercept from Tim Field and Brandon Cottons book on Social Game Design, focusing on monetization methods and mechanics.

Predicting Churn: Data-Mining Your Game

Dmitry Nozhnin provides an excellent account for how an indie company with no experience in data mining started looking into and predicting the behavior of their players. The follow up focuses on veteran players.

Presentations and events

Industry events are a great place to go to see presentations from people working with analytics from a variety of viewpoints. Analytics has in recent years become one of the major topics at e.g. the Game Developers Conference, Casual Connect, the GDC summits, Nordic Game and other big events. Most of these conferences make the presentations available after the conference, in some behind a paywall like GDC, in other instances openly available e.g. via YouTube (e.g. Casual Connect). There are currently somewhere between four to five dozen talks available online which focus on game analytics to a greater or lesser degree. A complete list is out of scope here, but we can mention a few:

Successful Instrumentation: Tracking Attitudes and Behaviors to Improve Games

Ramon Romero explained in detail at the Game Developers Conference in 2008 how user testing and user research go hand in hand with analytics, outlining how triangulation between methods were used to great effect during the development of the Halo series.

MMO Rapid Content Iteration using Spatial Analysis

Georg Zoeller, lately of Bioware, showed some stunning visualizations of spatial behavioral data from the MMORPG Star Wars The Old Republic at the Game Developers Conference in 2011. A source of great inspiration for those interested in investigating player behavior to improve game design. The work of Georg and his colleagues set a new standard for spatial visualization.

Beyond Metrics: Predictive Analytics, with Lessons from Related Industries

Nick Lim from Sonamine gave this presentation at Casual Connect in 2011. It is one of the first presentations to openly discuss the power of more sophisticated forms of data mining such as predictive analytics in a form and format that is broadly understandable. Nick Lim surveys the range of analytic goals and methods currently deployed for social media and for games, and present predictive analytics as a general social-network analytics framework with a view towards specific results for predicting customer-specific probabilities of conversion.

The Game Life-Cycle and Game Analytics: What Metrics Matter When?

Mark Gazecki from HoneyTracks gave this presentation at Casual Connect in 2012, focusing on identifying key metrics for monetization during different stages of the lifecycle of a casual/online game. One of Mark’s key points is that different metrics are important at different stages of the lifecycle of a game.

Challenges and Visions of Game Analytics

Yes, we know it is shameless self-promotion, but GA’s Anders Drachen gave a presentation at the 2012 Berlin Data Science Day on the future of game analytics, outlining some of the broader perspectives about analytics, including the ethical considerations a company needs to consider when working with personal data. Look for other great presentations from the same event from e.g. the incredibly succesful F2P provider Wooga.

Using Predictive Analytics to Drive Game Personalization

Chris Wright from Games Analytics presented some of his ideas towards using analytics as a source for driving game adaptation and individual experiences at Casual Connect 2012. He discusses various ideas and solutions as well as some of the ethical consideration involved.

Measure or Die: Analytics and F2P Mobile Game Design

Jefferson Valaderez discusses analytics for F2P games on mobile platforms, and the changes needed to game design strategies in order to flourish on the mobile market, including topics such as monetization, design iteration, engagement and retention.

Dear Indie Mobile Game Developer

This is an article by Eric Seufert, answering the most frequent questions he has received from indie mobile game developers regarding bringing their games to market. Seufert addresses the issues related to test marketing of the game, and talks about the analytics that support it.

Infographic: Who Works with Big Data?

Using a simple infographic format, Eric Seufert breaks down the variety of job titles within the field of Big Data. Setting buzz words aside, the infographic focuses on what the practitioners of big data analytics actually accomplish.

Ditch Tableau and use d3.js, Part 2 of 2: Access and allies

This article explores the subject of access to data – what are the ways organizations can approach it, who should have the access, and how to prevent unfortunate events, such as employees that are no longer with the organization still having access to internal data, from happening.

Video: Balancing free-to-play in Dungeons & Dragons Neverwinter

In this 23-minute video from Game Developers Conference (GDC) Europe 2013, Gabriel Hacker, the general manager of Perfect World in Europe, covers the launch of Dungeons & Dragons Neverwinter, as well as the strategy behind monetization of the game. Hacker also goes over the sales data, revealing that content updates, not sales or discounts, caused the biggest spikes in sales.

How Criminal Case Drives Growth

In this blog post, Michail Katkoff from Game Analytics focuses on game mechanics that drive growth for one of the best growing Facebook games – Criminal Case. The blog post covers the breakdown of the core loop, as well as retention, virality and monetization aspects of the game.

An Indie Perspective: Launching a F2P game

Time Wicksteed, who runs a one-man indie game studio called Twice Circled, based in Bristol, UK, wrote this guest post for Game Analytics. In the blog post, Wicksteed shares his perspective on the launch of his latest game, Ioanage, focusing on the performance of the F2P implementation.

Why Pet Rescue Saga isn’t the next Candy Crush Saga

This is another Game Analytics article exploring the field of Facebook games – this time the focus is on Pet Rescue Saga (PRS). While PRS is quite a hit on Facebook, Michail Katkoff, one of Game Analytics experts, examines factors such as focus on monetization, strategy, difficulty, graphics, storyline and others, to argue that PRS will not repeat the success of Candy Crush Saga.

The economics of mobile game publishing

In this blog post, Eric Seufert, a quantitative marketing and mobile user acquisition specialist, examines different publishing model scenarios. Seufert analyzes the factors a developer should take into account before signing a publisher agreement, modeling the revenue streams under each publishing scenario.

What the Gaming Industry Knows About Digital Intelligence

Joe Stanhope from Forrester Research argues that the Games Industry is ahead of its time when it comes to Digital Intelligence. Stanhope further identifies key Game Industry capabilities that organization could learn from, including management of big data, evaluation of complex customer experiences and continuous optimization.

Big data comes to games. How one company sees the future in personalized play.

Big data is bulging. This articles is based on an interview with Chethan Ramachadran, the CEO of Playnomics, discussing how the world of informatics will reshape play. Ramachadran describes the future as ‘personalized games’, arguing that there will still be a place for creativity and artistic expression.

Big Data and Games – part 1 – Why Ask Why

This is another interesting article on big data. Nick Lim, one of Gamasutra experts, explores the area and argues that knowing the reason ‘why’ certain big data findings are observed is not always necessary before the action is taken. Lim also tackles the implication for Game Analytics, giving advice to practitioners.

Big Data and Games – part 2 – Algorithms and Experts

In the second part of the article mentioned above, Nick Lim dives into the changing role of the subject matter experts. Describing the new, emerging big data expert, Lim discusses the implications for the industry, and explains how it could leverage the new specialists to improve upon design, marketing, and monetization.

Virtual Behavior Labs Discover What Gamers Want

This Virtual Labs article provides an overview of the world of data in game analytics. Some of the themes uncovered in the article include: the way game data can be used to study human behavior, the challenges that come with game data analytics, and the ethical aspect of studying user data.

How game developers can predict behavior patterns through rewards

This article is based on Ars Technica’s interview with Dr. David L. Roberts, an assistant professor at NCSU. Roberts uncovers the study behind his work on linking WoW rewards to player interest. Ultimately the analysis led to the ability of predicting user behavior based on acquired rewards, with an 80% accuracy.

Game On: Video Games Help Test Human Behavior

Without a doubt, the field of game analytics has great potential when it comes to increasing player engagement, improving game design & development, as well as monetization of the game. But game data has applications outside of the virtual world as well, by acting as a sandbox for studying human behavior. This Live Science article examines the implications for the real world, going over some of the studies, as well as the limitations for the approach.

Chasing the Whale: Examining the Ethics of Free-to-play Games

‘Whales’ is a term that describes players who spend large amounts on free-to-play games. Becoming addicted, the whales often can’t afford to pay rent or buy food, but keep buying the 99 cent add-ons in the game. This article examines the ethics behind free-to-play business models that completely rely of the contributions of whales, balancing out the 99% of players who don’t contribute a cent.

A comprehensive free-to-play game model: revenue, DAU, virality, and retention (spreadsheet included)

As the free-to-play model is growing and becoming one of the most dominant game models on mobile devices, developers face a growing need to understand the analytics behind it. In this blog post, Eric Seufert examines what factors contribute to the positive ROI of F2P games, and presents a tool that developers could use to make data-driven business decisions about the economic viability of their F2P games.

Is DAU The Ultimate Vanity Metric?

Tom Farrell, one of Gamasutra’s experts, wrote this post to argue that Daily Active Users (DAU) metric, despite its popularity among analysts, should not be used to measure the rate of success. Farrell argues that DAU is a ‘vanity metric’, as it makes the developers ‘feel good’ about their game. Later in the article Farrell proposes alternative metrics, such as new users, retention and conversion, as daily measures of success.

Around games

Because analytics is not just used in games but rather everywhere, there is a wealth of useful material in e.g. web analytics that can be adapted and adopted for use in games. The sheer scope of material available is too big to discuss here, but we can recommend the following books as being of particular interest to anyone interested in game analytics.

Competing on Analytics: The New Science of Winning

Thomas Davenport and Jeanne Harris has written this excellent introduction to analytics in business, focusing on the goal of obtaining data-driven insights rather than making decisions based on gut instinct. The authors provide a good overview of analytics in business contexts, and include a number of case examples that provide inspiration to game development as well, notably in the area of performance and production analytics.

Data Mining: Concepts and Techniques

Jiawei Han, Micheline Kamber and Jian Pei are not up to the third edition of this classical textbook about data mining. This book is for those who are interested in taking their analytics a step further, and begin explore more sophisticated methods such as prediction, clustering, and machine learning in general. Readable by non-experts, used as a textbook for tertiary students.

Web Analytics Demystified: A Marketer’s Guide to Understanding How Your Web Site Affects Your Business

Eric Peterson wrote this seminal guide to web analytics which democratized analytics for web sites, and brought the concept of actionable data to the masses. It is a very good introduction to web analytics, from where many of the key business metrics used in games such as DAU, MAU and ARPU have been directly derived. It is also written in straight-forward language.

Understanding Matching Estimators Using Jelly Beans

Heather Stark recently published a very interesting post on her blog, based on a talk by Christophe Safferling from Ubisoft. He talked about using matching estimators as an alternative to A/B testing in games – notably in situations where A/B testing is not possible – and that sparked Heather Stark’s curiosity, prompting this very interesting analysis and writeup. Head over there to read about jelly beans …

Research publications

Outside of the industry, an increasing number of academic researchers have started looking into game analytics, and a lot of very interesting knowledge is produced, although sometimes there is the problem that academic research needs a bit of translation before it can be adopted to a development context. However, there is a wealth of ideas to be found in academic research. More than 300 research publications exist that touch on game analytics in one way or another, here we mention but a few. Notice that most of these are behind publisher paywalls, but most local university libraries will have access, or alternatively chase down your cousins wife’s brother’s wife who is a professor to get them for you. Some people also make their publications available via their personal websites.

We will write more about these in the future, taking them up individually and in groups and describing the most essential results.

Here are a couple of examples:

Analytics of Play: Using Information Visualization and Gameplay Practices for Visualizing Video Game Data (Ben Medler and Brian Magerko)

How Players Loose Interest In Playing a Game (Christian Bauckhage et al.)

Spatial Game Analytics (Anders Drachen and Matthias Schubert)

Third-parties and tools

Finally, there are number of third-party developers who provide analytics services. Although typically focused on more than just games, some of these have useful material and guides on their websites which can be worth reading. Here are a few of them in no particular order of importance.

Sonamine

Tableau

Playnomics

HoneyTracks

PsychoStats (tool)

RapidMiner (tool)

Flurry

Playtomic

SteamWorks (website with analytics from Steam)

Kontagent

Weka (excellent open source data mining tool)

See the Game Analytics blog for additional material on how to get started with game analytics. 

2 thoughts on “Articles and Resources

  1. Pingback: Introducing Clustering I: Behavioral Profiling for Game Analytics | GameAnalytics Blog

  2. Pingback: Introducing Clustering I: Behavioral Profiling for Game Analytics | Game Analytics Resources v. Anders Drachen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s